Defined ambition has failed.
- This was mainly because, tasked with suggesting a less onerous alternative to defined benefit (DB) schemes that gave more protection than defined contribution (DC) schemes, the pensions industry (including actuaries) did not get behind the least bad option, but instead presented a spectrum of options
- The public and employers were unimpressed
- And employers had enough on their plate anyway dealing with auto-enrolment
- So they have now all (or nearly all) enrolled their employees into DC
- And the reason they are in DC now is the same reason they were in DB before: because they were offered so many choices they lost sight of the fact that there was a choice.
The time to significantly influence corporate pension provision would appear to have passed until people realise how hard it is to make sufficient provision via a DC scheme. That may not be until the money actually runs out as the finance industry has a proven track record in keeping people in schemes (eg the early personal pensions and later endowment mortgages) long after they retain the capacity to do them any good.
In the meantime, people with DC pensions and madly transferring DB members now have freedom and choice. I predict that this too will fail.
- This will mainly be because, tasked with providing cost-effective advice to people to empower them to make good decisions about their financial future, the pensions industry do not get their act together and just present a spectrum of options
- The public will be unimpressed
- And employers, who might have been persuaded to increase employee education and engagement in pensions, will have enough on their plate anyway dealing with auto-enrolment
- So now most of them will be managing their own retirement with not enough money, vulnerable to pensions scammers and paying far more tax than they need to
- And the reason they will not be in an annuity now is the same reason they were in one before: because they were offered so many choices (see the Pension Wise website, inexplicably still in an unfinished Beta state) they lost sight of the fact there was a choice.
The time to significantly influence individual pension provision appears to be rapidly running out.
How does this story end, I wonder?