Alan Milburn’s report about NEETS (young people not in education, employment or training), entitled From a Welfare State to a Working State, was published this week. I spent 10 years focused on delivering higher education programmes which very much did concern themselves with the what next question but am also quite a sceptic of the current government, so I felt both compelled to read the report and ready to be disappointed by what I found. I was expecting to find the blame for the current situation placed firmly on the “snowflake generation”. I didn’t.

Instead Milburn appears to have spoken to a lot of young people in producing both this report and the earlier interim diagnostic report and, as I have myself found throughout my career, been impressed by them. I found there was quite a lot in his reports to agree with.

First of all, the focus on the first rung on the career ladder is encouraging. As the report says:

Young people are not the same as older workers. The welfare system has treated them as though they are. They are not returning to something. They are trying to reach something for the first time.

Milburn concludes that a different system is required: “an active system which accords them new entitlements to propel them towards independence through earning or learning”.

Second, the expansion of apprenticeships, including degree apprenticeships, as a vehicle to reduce the risk to employers of taking on young workers who need significant training.

Third, the simplification of all the current entry routes into different types of work into a single Youth Opportunity Service is welcome, allowing a UCAS-style single front door to employment opportunities.

Fourth, it is a cross-government project, requiring coordination between the Department of Work and Pensions, the Department of Health and Social Care and the Department of Education. All three will need to drive through significant reforms for the project to work. The Prime Minister has put his weight behind it, suggesting that the funding will be found.

And, on that, this feels like the first example of how the preventative departmental expenditure limit or PDEL, sitting alongside the more familiar investment and resource spending limits and first set out in the Budget last month, might operate at scale. This is spending which reduces future costs, in this case benefit payments to young people who have been helped into employment via the measures set out here. This report is full of PDEL:

As upfront investment in enhanced opportunity and support takes effect, savings will start to come from reduced spending on benefits while increased revenues for the public purse will flow from more people being in work and paying their taxes. The positive fiscal impact increases with sustained growth in young people’s participation rates until the package achieves fiscal savings in 2036/37.

This is telling a different story from the fiscal space nonsense previously spouted by the OBR.

But more than anything, at a time when every headline seems to be a new restriction on the young, restricting their access to everything from cigarettes to the internet to relationships with older men to social media to their own mobile phones, these are measures aimed at giving young people more opportunities and access. Some of the statistics are striking:

In 2023/24 ICBs [integrated care boards] spent just 1.04 per cent of their total spend on young people’s mental health. On average they spent 13 times more on adult than on young people’s mental health services.

One of the key aims of the reforms are to:

…move the needle on the ratio spent on young people between income replacement and employment support. At present for every £25 we spend on benefits we only spend £1 on support. As a result of these changes, within the next 10 years that ratio should be £2 to £1.

Now for the scepticism.

A role for mayors appears to have been inserted into nearly everything, which I expect to trigger unnecessary turf wars, at least at the outset. The way the previous Thrive into Work programme was shut down may mean some trust issues amongst the people the government would be hoping to recruit to their new scheme. The wait period for the Jobs Guarantee of 12 months (down from 18 months) is still too long. A lot hinges on digital mental health services being scaled up and accessed successfully by the young to free up community resource elsewhere. It is unclear how employers are going to be encouraged to keep on young workers after their 6 month subsidised period of employment ends. A sense of national mission will be required which I am not sure is there at the moment. And, in view of the need for long term funding and commitment to effect change here, will the PDEL be as protected from budgetary pressures as advertised? The FT regards it as “contentious” and other critics are considerably more trenchant. Some of the wider points about how to support young people to develop fulfilling careers in an employment landscape increasingly dominated by ways of avoiding training them, which I have been writing about for much of this year, remain largely unaddressed.

The biggest danger highlighted by the critics is that, without doing enough to boost the economy we are sending these young people into, we are risking creating, at great expense, a lot of temporary low quality jobs which do not give young people anything meaningful to build on. As Roy Lilley says:

The NHS is being pressured to sack experienced staff and will now be pressured to employ novices.

Yesterday, our biggest defence supplier BAE Systems announced it’s making 1,000 people redundant… what price an apprenticeship with them, now?

The employer experiences the totality of policy.

The suspicion must be, particularly as he appears to be making this a central plank of his government, that the Prime Minister has a primarily political objective here. The next United Kingdom general election is scheduled to be held no later than 15 August 2029.

Look at the proposed timeline for the roll out of the policy:

2027/2028
The first major delivery changes should come into operation in 2027/2028. During this period every area should develop a Participation Plan and the central YOS function should be mobilised. Existing employment, careers and youth services can then be brought together, with the new data infrastructure developed that enables the early identification of hidden NEETs and those at risk of becoming so. The roll out of Early Support Hubs is already in progress across England. This should be accelerated, and it is critical that there is also a rapid expansion of wider mental health and community-based support during this time. This will be complemented by the development of the digital offer, so that these services are available to young people as soon as possible.

In 2028, all established MSAs should have Participation Agreements in place and delivering a YOS model that both meets the national standards and the needs of their local area. For young people, this will mean they have a more joined-up experience of support across different services. Where areas haven’t stood up a YOS, there should be structured interim programmes that deliver similar services. As areas begin to establish their full suite of support, all young people living there should be increasingly supported by the YOS. It is likely that some places will be able to achieve full system integration much more quickly than others – the learnings from these leading authorities should be shared and used to refine wider implementation. In terms of opportunity creation, these first years should be about taking the immediate steps to stimulate demand by significantly expanding the Youth Jobs Grant, the Jobs Guarantee, supported internships, and clarifying legislation around youth hiring. The funding, capacity and infrastructure to radically increase further education, deliver a new pre-apprenticeship pathway, and incentivise employers to take on more apprentices will also need to be built during this period. In education settings, the focus should be on preventing disengagement and improving transition points. Improved data, key stage 3 checks and more flexible curriculum time should enable schools to identify difficulties sooner and provide targeted support before young people fall out of education. Strategic authorities should map and publish local routes from education into work and study both for the benefit of young people, and to understand where there are gaps. These reforms should reduce the risk of young people being left without a route when a course ends or breaks down, resulting in smoother transitions.

2029 onwards
By the end of 2029, every area should have a YOS or equivalent offer in place. Health should be fully integrated into regional governance. The Opportunity offer, Support offer and Health & Disability Fund offers should be guaranteed for any young person that needs them. This means that local health, employment, skills and welfare support must be all under a common plan and be able to deliver in a timely way and at the capacity and quality to meet demand. Once an area has sufficiently established their YOS and connected support, all new claims for benefits for 18 to 24 year-olds will be to Youth Allowance, Additional Costs Allowance and the Severe and Complex Needs Insurance in that area. Those on legacy benefits (UC, UC Health, PIP) will be assessed in the new youth benefit system at their scheduled reassessment date following a 6 month preparation period with the YOS where they can take up the new support and opportunity offers and prepare for the transition from old system to new.

There is the possibility of some sweet spot in this policy’s development where a large number of young people are in jobs, the money is still there and the targets for what should have happened by the end of 2029 have not yet been tested. That is when I imagine the election will be called.

And then? Well of course all kinds of things might happen over the next 10 years, and probably will. To return to Lilley:

His wider programme runs towards 2036, potentially across three parliaments, AI, redundancy, wars, techno-hacks and goodness knows what.

And, as he points out:

HMG has to find the bandwidth to…

  • Cut the waiting lists.
  • Increase defence spending.
  • Build homes.
  • Reform social care.
  • Tee-up the EU for round-two.
  • Improve productivity.
  • Re-dis-organise the NHS, and…

… add a ten-year reconstruction of how government helps young people into work.

It ain’t gonna happen.

What would my advice be for young people entering this newly-tinkered-with jobs market? Much as before. Remember what a reverse-centaur is? (Cory Doctorow defines a reverse-centaur as “a machine that is assisted by a human being, who is expected to work at the machine’s pace”).

The risks of becoming a reverse-centaur have not been reduced at all. Indeed they may be increased if Amazon responds to the subsidies on offer at the scale I think they might: plenty of reverse-centaur jobs available in their vans and fulfillment centres. This would be regarded as a success by the government.

So how to avoid this outcome? As I suggested previously, the questions to ask at interview to identify whether the role is irretrievably reverse-centauresque would be of the following sort (and both the increase in the supply of roles and the need for employers to attract under 25s to claim the subsidy does shift the balance of power ever so slightly in your direction at interview stage):

  1. How big a team would I be working in? (This might not identify a reverse-centaur role on its own: you might be one of a bank of reverse-centaurs all working in parallel and identified “as a team” while in reality having little interaction with each other).
  2. What would a typical day be in the role? This should smoke it out unless the smokescreen they put up obscures it. If you don’t understand the first answer, follow up to get specifics.
  3. Who would I report to? Get to meet them if possible. Establish whether they are technical expert in the field you will be working in. If they aren’t, that means you are!
  4. Speak to someone who has previously held the role if possible. Although bear in mind that, if it is a true reverse-centaur role and their progress to an actual centaur role is contingent on you taking this one, they may not be completely forthcoming about all of the details.

To which I would now add a 5th:

5. What are your plans for when the government subsidy runs out?

We’d all like to hear the answer to that one.

Source: Universal Pictures Publicity, Fair use, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?curid=71354716

10 years ago I was working my way through Cathy O’Neill’s excellent Weapons of Math Destruction, the first really loud warning about the inappropiate application of algorithms, and blogging about it. In the book she set out the case against devolving important decisions to mathematical models without adequate feedback loops. Yes, 10 years ago!

I concluded that post by paraphrasing Robert Oppenheimer’s words about the Manhattan Project:

If mathematical models are to be the dominant regulatory tool of a financial world, and of the consultancies and financial firms competing in that world, then the time will come when mankind will curse the names of the highly paid professionals who followed inappropriate rules rather than exercising their own expert judgement when it mattered.

I think that is still a work in progress. Although at least they have made a film about the Manhattan Project in the meantime. And you could say the United States certainly appear to be embracing the analogy:

Meanwhile Cathy O’Neill has done a lot more than just wring her hands about these risks. She has set up her own consultancy (O’Neil Risk Consulting & Algorithmic Auditing or ORCAA) to audit your algorithms for you. As she says:

Whether it’s a hiring algorithm, healthcare AI, predictive scoring system, or generative AI platform, we are here to think about how it could fail, for whom, and what you can do to monitor and mitigate these risks. We are actively developing frameworks and governance approaches to help companies and organizations use algorithms and AI safely – confirming these technologies perform as intended and operate within sensible guardrails. We help our clients realize the transformative benefits of AI, while avoiding discrimination, bias, and other problems.

Their offering includes:

  • Algorithmic audit, including generative AI, automated decision systems, predictive models, and facial recognition;
  • Quantitative testing for regulatory compliance;
  • AI Governance and Risk Management Consultation;
  • What they call “Cockpit design” – “To make an effective cockpit, you must understand what can go wrong in flight, and include dials/gauges that monitor for those risks. We help build cockpits for your AI systems”; and
  • Education and Training.

ORCAA have been going for 7 years now, with a range of high profile clients, including AirBnB, Siemens and the City of Amsterdam.

This seems to me a good example of expertise being used in the right way.

I think I may have been naive.

A couple of weeks ago I took the IFoA’s AI Manifesto to task for wanting to be on the Red Team rather than the Blue Team, ie the one supposed to be stopping as many AI errors as possible. As I said then:

The Red Team breaks into systems by exploiting a single vulnerability. That is comparatively easy. The Blue Team needs to reassure its clients that it has removed ALL vulnerabilities.

But what if you are not working to protect people from vulnerabilities? What if you are working to protect and accumulate capital instead?

Today I was alerted to the latest article from the IFoA GenAI Working Party, Agent Skills in the Enterprise: Making Actuarial Process Knowledge Reusable. It explains “how an agent skill package can connect reusable instructions with scripts, controlled references, templates, examples and tests”. This will allow organisations to “preserve not only completed models, reports and workpapers, but also the process checks, review decisions and handling of exceptions that produced them using the “agent skill” framework”. As the report puts it:

The problem is not simply that organisations need better prompts. They are preserving the outputs of professional work while leaving much of the procedure that produced them implicit. A completed report records what was concluded. It rarely records every data check, exception, escalation point and review decision needed to reach the conclusion reliably next time.

I can immediately see the motivation. I have been that person trying to replicate a previous valuation result produced by a former colleague I can’t contact, with incomplete data and a-no-longer-supported valuation system which keeps going on the blink. But it was the mention of process knowledge which caught my attention.

I wrote about process knowledge and its importance around a year ago, citing the example of the shrines at Ise Jingu in Japan (which I had learned about from Dan Wang’s Breakneck). This is a now over 1,300 year project to preserve the traditional techniques of building these shrines which involve no nails, just dowels and wood joints. Skills are passed from one generation to the next, there is a tree planting programme which has survived a dozen or more historical eras, pandemics, volcanic eruptions, earthquakes, invasions and oh so many wars over that period. As well as two nuclear bombs.

The important thing is not the ability to build a shrine over 1,300 years later exactly as it was built then of course. It is a proof of concept. It has preserved intricate difficult skills over more than a millenium. And it has involved people, lots and lots of people.

By contrast, the IFoA project has a different, rather shorter term, goal, which is laid out as follows:

This is the first of five articles. The second examines how completed work can become reusable packages. The third introduces SkillOps as the discipline for governing agent skill packages in actuarial work. The fourth considers the consequences for consulting when expertise previously carried through human capital is codified in reusable agent skill packages and becomes intellectual property. The fifth places skills within the wider challenge of continual learning.

It is the fourth article which really bothers me. Once not just the details of a project, but all of the other parts which do not normally get passed on (ie the process knowledge) are captured in this system, it becomes intellectual property, which Cory Doctorow defines as:

any rule, law or policy that allows a company to exert control over its critics, competitors or customers

Up until now, process knowledge has not been given much attention, mainly because it can’t be turned into intellectual property. Process knowledge has always been what remains in the heads of the skilled technicians employed by businesses after everything not nailed down which can be taken ownership of by those businesses has been. Process knowledge has always been the nailed down part. It is the part that has allowed the last vestiges of worker power within most corporations to survive.

Now a group of actuaries think they have come up with a plan to monetize that for the firm as well. To pull up those last remaining nails of worker power.

Think how the IFoA GenAI Working Party would have approached the Ise Jingu shrines.

First you outsource the tree planting programme to a specialist forestry manager. Minimum tender of course: need to get maximum value for money here. Don’t worry about having control over the delivery of timber of just the right type in just the right condition for a unique project. Just leave that to the specialists working on a budget.

Then you sit with the old guys taking you through the various processes involved. Might need some video capture for some of it. Make sure everything they say is captured and then cross-referenced for easier access subsequently. Don’t take too long over it as time is money. Don’t actually feel what it’s like to work with the tools, just note down everything about tool selection. Don’t actually apply the required pressure in the right direction with respect to the grain of the wood, its dryness, the precise cut from the trees selected. Just make sure the video is high enough quality.

I would be surprised if this project survived 20 years. In fact, in view of the fantasy economics of the AI industry, I would be surprised if it lasted even five years if the AI Agents involved in this project relied to any degree on the survival of any of the Magnificent 7.

And this is just to build a shrine out of wood.

These two projects are doing two different things. One is trying to preserve a human activity over a non-trivial period of time. The other is attempting to monetize it so that it can be included in the bottom line for the next quarter. And perhaps to float the idea that your business might be able to dispense with those pesky new employees acquiring process knowledge.

Which brings me to another alarm call. This time from an anonymous group of senior professionals in the UK and European insurance and reinsurance industries called Sounding the Alarm and published in English, French and German. It is not long, so I urge you to read it, but I want to focus on this passage about how the insurance industry is responding to the climate crisis:

Our industry’s strategy is to manage renewals in order to limit our exposure as the physical risk manifests so that premiums are sufficient to cover the rising claims load. This is not a malicious act but a simple response to the commercial realities we are faced with.

We will do this in three ways which many clients are unaware of and governments across Europe are failing to internalise the consequences of:

Firstly, we will reprice our cover. We will simply make policies much more expensive to reflect this elevated physical risk and uncertainty. This will have wider consequences for economic inequality, making it harder for less affluent households to access insurance. It will also increase costs for critical industries such as farming or shipping , creating a significant social and financial burden for government s and, in turn, its taxpayers.

Secondly, we will limit coverage to exclude elevated risks such as wildfires as well as other less predictable risks . The nature of insurance being re – negotiated on a 12 – month basis allows us to do this without friction. Ensuring customers really understand that this is happening is critical.

Thirdly, if there is no way to bring premiums and claims into balance or introduce risk reduction measures we will – for certain geographies and sectors – simply withdraw coverage . This will particularly affect coastal, mountain and flood-prone communities.

This approach is our way of managing our own financial exposure and maintaining profitability at a time of increasing physical risk and increasing uncertainty. Doing so is critical to ensure we can continue to pay claims, therefore fulfilling both our fiduciary duty and our role in society.

This is the flipside of the capitalisation of process knowledge of course. If it can no longer be monetized then ditch it, all the while spouting about “our role in society”. The people on the receiving end will not care whether it is a malicious act or not, it will feel like one.

Both of these stories tell us which side many actuaries are on, and it is the side of capital rather than the side of the people from who it has been extracted. It is not malicious, and it is how many actuaries understand fiduciary duty. To the contract rather than to public interest.

I look back on my own actuarial career. Some time as a scheme actuary where I really felt I was safeguarding the pensions of ordinary people, some time protecting the wealth of already fairly wealthy people from the tax authorities, some time in insurance feeling really quite remote from customers of any kind. And then 10 years helping students into actuarial work. Have I really just been a tool of capital this whole time? Is this why a IFoA sustainability WhatsApp group, which is all about connecting sustainability thought leaders together and raising awareness of the impact of the climate emergency across the finance sector (where I first saw the Sounding the Alarm memo), is so small?

Dan Davies, highlighting Robin Wriggleworth’s new book, A Fabulous Debt: The Epic Story of How Bonds Built the Modern World, wonders whether life insurance actuaries and general insurance actuaries (referred to as casualty actuaries here) have a similar relationship as bond traders and equity traders. It’s a good read. There is even a reference to Craig Turnbull’s magisterial A History of British Actuarial Thought! And this is the conclusion:

Which leads me to the paradox of the title. Reading the histories of actuaries, there seems to be quite a similar needle between the life and non-life insurers; one group place their trust in the higher mathematics, the other deals with heuristics, rules of thumb and vibes. It all comes to a head when you have to draw up the accounts, of course – the big intellectual battle seems to have been the casualty actuaries’ practice of setting reserves depending on the sum of each individual policy, which is really contrary to the spirit of treating risks as draws from a single distribution.

So it makes me think that there is some potential general principle here. Fields of human endeavour where management makes most use of complicated mathematics are likely to be less intrinsically complex and difficult. We use quantitative techniques only when we are content with regarding something as quantifiable.

This feels like a possible explanation. If your acknowledged expertise is in clever mathematics, you are likely to favour techniques which make more things quantifiable and therefore manipulable with clever mathematics. And the more actuaries flood into new fields, the further the quantifying will go.

Capitalism has always been in the business of quantifying things, allocating them to someone (often using considerable violence to do so) and then selling them as property. But late-stage capitalism has a now almost cartoonish obsession with quantifying even things that cannot be easily or successfully quantified, extracting ownership of the thing at the point of quantifying it and then selling it on.

When all the process knowledge has been turned into intellectual property, proprietary knowledge behind paywalls that hide the fact that it doesn’t really work any more, businesses will start to realise that they still have important gaps that are now nearly impossible to fill. There may be a Sounding the Alarm memo about it from anonymous insiders.

But it will be too late by then.

We shall not cease from exploration
And the end of all our exploring
Will be to arrive where we started
And know the place for the first time.

T.S. Eliot – Four Quartets

I feel like I am having a bit of a T.S. Eliot week. I have been writing about the OBR since the beginning of this blog in 2013, with their repeated failures as a forecaster forming the banner for the blog for many years.

What has brought me back to the OBR, as if for the first time, is recalling during the recent Funding the Future conference the words of the very good and wise friend of mine who was there with me. I had invited him to talk to one of my undergraduate groups at the University of Leicester during a professional skills session a few years ago. We were looking at past disciplinary cases of the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries and discussing what the actuaries involved could have done better.

In one of the case studies we considered, an actuary had produced a quarterly reserving report for a company, estimating the reserves on a ‘high’ basis of £74.5 million, a ‘low’ basis of £36.9 million and a ‘best’ basis of £52.1 million. The company then produced financial statements for the year, approved by the board of which he was a part, containing a reserve figure of £15.5 million. My friend told the students that the way to challenge in a situation like this is not to focus on the numbers, but instead see that each different number reflects a different story being told. So you need to look at what the story would need to be for the £15.5 million to be an appropriate figure and take issue with the things that don’t make sense within that story.

It was great advice then and still is, and it is definitely the way to look at the OBR I think. We find a story unsatisfactory if the characters are shallow, do not behave in a credible way, and the plot oversimplifies a much richer situation (something which every story must do to some extent to be manageable to the reader) in a deeply unsatisfying way.

Several other commentators have talked about the inability of the OBR to forecast anything (including me) – this is the equivalent of insufficiently fleshed out characters behaving in unbelievable ways. Richard Murphy, for instance, pointed out how ridiculous the proposed character plotline for inflation was at the last budget:

Whereas in fact of course the downward trajectory predicted at the last budget didn’t look remotely likely even then. The Consumer Prices Index (CPI) rose by 3.1% in the 12 months to August 2026, up from 2.9% the previous month.

However it is Dan Davies’ recent couple of Substack posts (one and two) which get to the heart of the problem in my view. Dan Davies’ contention is that it is the plot oversimplification which is the main problem here. As he says:

The system we have set up only seems to be able to communicate two states though – the signal is either “COMPLIANT – WAR CHEST” or “NONCOMPLIANT – BLACK HOLE”. It would be a significant improvement even for the OBR to add some measure of urgency or non-urgency to its press release – a sentence like “this surplus is well within the forecast error, however, so it should not be used to justify a change in policy”.

But, in his view, it is even worse than that:

In general, most things which a government spends money on will tend to have effects on the economy which go well beyond the five year forecast. The OBR uses an information set which contains only a small and quite arbitrary subset of government decisions – it is, literally, not capable of representing the system it is meant to control at an acceptable level of accuracy.

The justification for ignoring the future consequences of current spending seems to be no more sophisticated than what we pejoratively call “Treasury Brain” – the belief that a) spending departments always claim that their budget should be seen as an investment, b) that they systematically overestimate the long term benefits of current costs and c) that the best solution to a) and b) is to completely ignore any future benefits from investment or future costs caused by noninvestment. It’s just not good enough.

It is this dog’s breakfast that apparently tells us whether we are on track to meet the plotline the government has set for itself. Its three fiscal rules:

Rule 1. The current budget should be on course to be in balance or surplus by 2029/30 (‘stability rule’);

Rule 2. Net financial debt should fall as a share of the economy in 2029/30 (‘investment rule’); and

Rule 3. Some types of welfare spending must remain below a pre-specified level (the ‘welfare cap’).

And if that gruesome threesome doesn’t set your heart racing about the country’s future story, you are not alone. Because the people banging on about fiscal space will always push for governments to spend less, regardless of the circumstances. For instance, at the height of the pandemic in December 2020, Moody’s were saying this (with excess deaths already estimated at over 30,000 in the UK by Public Health England at that point):

However, compared to the government’s March budget (that was quickly overtaken by events), there are some initial signs that fiscal policy outside of investment is likely to be less expansive than previously announced. What remains unclear is whether this ambition will be able to withstand the political pressures that seem to be inevitable given the government’s previous commitments. Even before the Spending Review, longer-term spending commitments for health, education, and defence had already been announced. Together, these three areas account for around 60% of total expenditure.

One of the themes from the Funding the Future conference was, to quote from Educating Rita:

“There must be better songs to sing than this”.

I agree. One possibility is proposed by the New Economics Foundation, who suggest categorising policies by their level of multiplier effect (ie how much economic activity is increased by an increase in spending) and replacing fiscal rules with a “fiscal referee” who can make a more holistic judgement addressing many of the omissions Dan Davies complains about. This would then lead to a discussion rather than the compliant/non-compliant cliff edge we currently have, and allow the government to make its case. And it would not automatically incentivise cuts like the current system does.

Other possibilities exist. As Dan Davies describes it:

any accounting system is a mental prison of some kind, and one which needs to be periodically escaped from

In my view, a jailbreak is long overdue.

A no entry sign over an image of a reverse-centaur where the robot is in control

Last month the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries (IFoA) launched what it calls its “AI Manifesto“. I thought I would take a look.

The Manifesto is admirably short and to the point. Its pitch can be summarised by this final line of its Introduction and context:

For the benefit of society, we encourage those responsible for developing and deploying AI systems to ensure that there is an actuary in the loop.

Think of it as a massive “Gissa job” plea to those companies currently investing in AI systems. But what sort of jobs are we pleading for?

The idea is that actuaries have been working with models which use machine learning for many years, that we have statistical expertise, are comfortable working with data, used to stress-testing systems and also to looking at the risk appetite of a business as a whole.

I think the first hint that there might be a problem here is when the Manifesto moves onto ethics and the public interest. As it says:

Actuaries help teams balance commercial aims with societal expectations, offering constructive solutions rather than imposing limits.

It is difficult to square this with Anthropic‘s recent IPO filing, where they warn its technology may pose “existential risks to humanity”. I am pretty confident that Society expects not to be put at existential risk. So if Anthropic thinks its technology is that dangerous, there is no balance to be found between commercial aims and societal expectations here. Societal expectations are paramount. And limits will need to be imposed rather than “constructive solutions”.

But, in my view, the main problem here is what “real world” the IFoA feel they are serving. This comes through in the role for “professionalism” they envisage:

Projects with sound validation, honest documentation and clear accountability clear governance more quickly, avoid late-stage rework, and fail in testing rather than in production. Professionalism is what lets an organisation say “yes” to AI with confidence – and protects it from the adverse outcomes that would otherwise force it to say “no”.

This, remember, is in an environment where the latest large language models like Anthropic’s Claude Opus 5.5 or OpenAI’s GPT-6 Astra, are proprietary models where validation, documentation, accountability and governance are all just what they let you see. A framework which allows companies to say yes with misplaced confidence is unlikely to be serving the public interest. And translating a capacity to apply a regulatory model to an insurance company where you have all the data and can make informed judgements about the things that you don’t know (Actuaries are used to working with large, imperfect, transactional datasets subject to audit and regulatory scrutiny. We clarify what data is needed, what quality level is acceptable, and how data should be checked, reconciled and monitored over time) is emphatically not the same as working with a model where you don’t know precisely how it works, cannot accurately predict the errors it will make and do not have enough time to look in all of the places you need to.

Take bias for instance. The Manifesto says:

We examine how a model behaves for different groups and sub-groups, test whether training data is representative of the people the system will affect, and help manage the biases we find responsibly through fairness metrics for predictive models, and output audits and red-teaming for generative systems.

Nita Farahany in the law and policy course documented in her Thinking Freely Substack demonstrates the limits of that bias management in practice, and this is Cory Doctorow on red-teaming (from Red Team Blues):

That’s the problem with blue teaming it—you need to be perfect, while—The red team only has to find a single error

Yes, that’s right, the IFoA haven’t even understood that they are on the Blue Team when it comes to AI errors, ie the one supposed to be stopping as many of them as possible. The Red Team breaks into systems by exploiting a single vulnerability. That is comparatively easy. The Blue Team needs to reassure its clients that it has removed ALL vulnerabilities.

That will be the role of any “actuary in the loop”. And the chances are it won’t be possible. The three examples given by the IFoA are as follows:

A generative AI customer assistant
An insurer wants an LLM-based assistant to answer customer queries. An actuary designs the evaluation
framework: a curated test set of realistic queries, explicit tolerances for error, escalation rules for high-stakes topics, and live monitoring of answer quality. The project clears internal governance at the first attempt because approvers can see exactly what “good enough” means and how it is evidenced.

A machine-learning decision model
A lender deploys an ML model to score applications. An actuary tests behaviour across customer sub-groups,
identifies a data artefact that disadvantages one segment, and works with the data science team to correct it. The documentation of that judgement becomes the centrepiece of a constructive conversation with the regulator.

AI risk across an organisation
A Chief Risk Officer faces AI adoption in a dozen business units at once. An actuary helps articulate an enterprise AI risk appetite, maps where the organisation depends on the same foundation models, and builds board reporting that distinguishes experimentation from deployment. The organisation accelerates adoption in low-risk areas precisely because it now knows where the high-risk areas are.

None of these examples look unreasonable in isolation, but, to justify the eye-watering expense of this technology, it will need to increase speed and capacity significantly. So, rather than a single generative AI customer assistant, imagine a client relationship management role where a junior actuary or senior student manages 10 times the current expected number of clients at the same time, because the generative AI customer assistant makes that possible?

Will the skills of an actuary versed in the intricacies of Solvency 2 or pensions regulation be so revered by your client that you would be given more than enough time to rubber stamp a system serving 30 or 40 clients? How long do you think you’d need to check the output on all of them properly? I think it unlikely you will be given that long.

This is the risk of becoming a reverse centaur, where you work for the assistant rather than the other way around. And my view is that the actuarial education system is positively encouraging the development of reverse centaurs amongst our current students.

It gets worse. The early evidence suggests that working with AI systems encourages rubber stamping. In one study of AI-generated audits with an auditor in the loop, 150 of the 160 reports were submitted without any changes made by the human. The performance of humans in the loop may also be adversely affected by working with AI systems, leading to “agency decay”:

Agency decay is the gradual erosion of a person’s ability and willingness to observe carefully, think independently, choose deliberately, and act responsibly. It does not arise because AI is inherently harmful. It arises when convenience becomes the default setting for cognition. A tool that first helps us think can begin to think around us, then for us, then without us noticing what has been weakened.

There are lessons to be learned from other professions who have been working for much longer with expert systems. The aviation industry for example. As Craig Bright, Co-Chief Operating Officer at Barclays has posted:

So the test shouldn’t be whether a human appears somewhere on the process map.

It’s whether the system remains understandable, controllable and recoverable when the agent is wrong, uncertain or unavailable.

Safety doesn’t come from leaving a human in the loop.

It comes from designing a system the human can still control.

The IFoA’s position appears contradictory. On the one hand, they clearly don’t believe that AI is as powerful or as dangerous as Anthropic are claiming in order to push up the IPO share price, or I assume they would not be pushing so hard to get an actuary on every team “developing and deploying AI systems”. I think they are right not to believe it, for a number of reasons, but Naomi Alderman’s AI predictions: seven ways you can tell useful thinking from sci-fi fantasies gives probably the most entertaining ones.

On the other hand, if this is just another technology for which the price is going to need to adjust to reality at some point, we need to be very careful as a profession not to be part of the mob urging their clients to adopt it at a faster rate than they would otherwise. Particularly if it is damaging our own professionals in the process.

AI in some form will survive the inevitable crash, but the shape and scope of the wreckage that will be left behind is currently hard to predict. Let’s be careful what we wish for.

Source: https://xkcd.com/2347 This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 2.5 License

Last week I suggested that the period of disruption we have entered would be likely to impact the relationship between society and its institutions and professions, and likened those institutions and professions to the models behind the models we normally focus on. I suggested that this has serious implications for actuarial education, amongst much else.

This week I want to expand a little on what I meant by that.

First, the impact of AI. My view of AI is that I don’t believe most of the claims coming out of OpenAI and Anthropic when noone else gets to see the data and they clearly have a vested interest in playing up the capabilities of their systems. And I certainly don’t believe the fantasy economics the Magnificent 7 are currently indulging in is sustainable (see Ed Zitron’s Hater’s Guide to Circular Financing for more on this). But I do believe that there is a lot of political power with an increasingly out of control stake in it continuing, which makes the quote often attributed to Keynes (“Markets can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent”, although it may have been A. Garry Shilling in 1999) even more relevant here.

However, what cannot be denied is that the existence of AI is accelerating conversations which we should have been having a long time ago. Last month, MIT issued a report called AI and Education, which turns out to be more a philosophical musing about what we should be trying to achieve in universities, and what expectations we should have of both staff and students. It’s not a long report, but for the time poor amongst you there are two passages from this that I’d like to highlight here.

First, on the expectations we should have of students:

Leaning into learning means creating a new “social contract” between teachers and students. All of us who teach at MIT will need to be prepared to help students understand both that the process of education is necessarily a productive struggle, and that the most important product of their education is not a GPA or a diploma but themselves: their personal growth and intellectual maturity and the development of their own imagination, insight, and judgment.

Instilling these attitudes needs to become a central task for every educator, so that our students know not only what they should learn, but also how they should learn and why learning matters. We need to help them develop metacognitive abilities to think about thinking, to engage in reflective practices, and to enhance their sense of personal agency. This will require both dedication and fresh preparation on the part of instructors.

Remember that social contract idea, because it will be coming up again.

Second, on what kinds of assessments we need to move to in anything we still want to be able to refer to as education:

Rather than simply “AI-proof” current methods of assessment, instructors need to revisit what they really want students to know and devise assessments that foster, or even include, the kind of productive struggle that builds durable understanding and mastery.

We urge instructors to consider forms of assessment that are less vulnerable to AI, and more valuable for learning, such as oral exams, semester portfolios, and out-of-class assignments paired with in-class conversations. This likely means resources such as TAs and class time will become more central to evaluation.

and this:

To match the shift towards assessment methods that aren’t vulnerable to AI, instructors need to increase the role of experiential and project-based learning. To encourage this kind of creative teaching, MIT should support the development of teaching skills and practices for all instructors, and recognize contributions in this domain.

As someone who has already spent some time advocating just such a move in higher education, I feel quite vindicated. But back to that social contract point. I am in a WhatsApp group called Actuarial Change in Education (A C E), where we have been discussing this point for a while, but couldn’t agree what to call it. Culture was one proposal, but I think we all agreed on the MIT point that it should be aiming to ensure:

our students know not only what they should learn, but also how they should learn and why learning matters

And then, like buses, a third take on this point came from, of all people, Seth Godin in Two schools of thought about school:

One kind of school is about culture, compliance and community. We indoctrinate kids, for better or worse, in what it means to be in this world we’ve built, and how to do it together. We teach them how to be kids, how to be citizens and hopefully, how to be adults.

And the other kind of school is about the content. All the ‘R’s. The software that goes with the operating system we taught in the other school.

The first paragraph is what MIT and my WhatsApp group are referring to. It is the bit which has been assumed we shared in common for too long, but is the most important bit. A shared culture or social contract would allow us to meet and discuss things within a shared set of assumptions about how we can get agreement and take action. It is what has been holding back COPs and peace talks and politics more generally for my whole lifetime. It is also how we decide what we put in the second paragraph, which is necessarily stuff which will be being tweaked constantly and be much more short-term in focus..

The second paragraph is what the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries respond with when you ask them about education (I am only picking on them as this is the one I am most familiar with). Curriculum. Syllabus items. Suggested number of hours study. Past papers to practise for the traditional written exam.

Seth Godin calls this software. It is content. It is largely ephemeral, as the needs of the model we operate in and the tools we are given to do so change all the time. Little of it will survive a decade let alone a career. It does not encourage looking up and wondering if there is a better way. It is full of short-term deadlines and urgency and immediacy. Which tends to get confused with importance.

But the software will never surprise you or deal with situations noone has ever met before. If it is not in the underlying model, it will not turn up in the software. The important education is in the operating system. That is what needs to be reformed.

As I said, there is a WhatsApp group discussing such questions regularly. We are a small group currently, but would welcome new members interested in these questions. If you are, then respond to me in the comments section below or via a LinkedIn message if you are reading it there.

A little more information about A C E is set out below:

What is A C E?

Actuarial Change in Education. A place to discuss where change is needed in how actuarial students learn and the changing landscape they are preparing themselves for. A place to argue about how we teach, and how we get students to care about why they are in education and question the assumptions underlying it. A place to share thoughts and ideas you have had or seen about education, actuarial or otherwise. A place to collaborate with others equally concerned about the future of actuarial education. A place to plan and deliver communications with the wider actuarial community.

What are A C E’s aims?

To have an impact on actuarial education by providing a place for developing actionable ideas about education more generally and how they can be applied to actuarial studies in particular. The hope is that these will then be a useful resource for when the need for alternatives gains a wider acceptance.

Who can join A C E?

Anyone interested in the development of actuarial students.

Copper parts of a vehicle have been mounted on a much larger wooden structure in an exhibit at the Vatican Museums
My photograph of an exhibit at the Vatican Museums

Worldbuilding in science fiction has certain rules, or so I thought. And the first of these according to some sources at least seems to be consistency. According to the Quirkworthy website:

The basic message is very simple: your world must be internally consistent. Doesn’t matter if it’s science fiction or fantasy, and it makes no odds if it’s a novel, game, or opera. At all times, your world must be consistent to itself.

So when Jeff Noon and Steve Beard came to the Birmingham Science Fiction Group a couple of years ago, I pricked up my ears when one of them (Jeff I think) said that the first book of the Ludwich Chronicles, Gogmagog, which they were discussing, was not consistent. They were following Cady Meade’s viewpoint which journeyed 60 miles along the river Nysis inside a ghost and the focus was to set a particular mood. It was built from the bottom up.

This idea appealed to me then, and has, in my view, become a more and more important idea recently. We all build our views of the world from the bottom up based on our own experiences and they are frequently inconsistent with those of other people. The problem comes when we stop accepting that and treat our models as, in some way, top down and universal.

I had a great example of this a few years ago in the Vatican Museums. Some bits of bronze they reckoned to be parts of a cart buried in an Etruscan tomb had been discovered and were then displayed on an entirely speculative wooden model of a cart (to be fair to them, the Monteleone chariot dated to around 530 BC, was a rather more complete find and the wooden model looks like it was modelled on that). The trouble is, once you have seen the pieces on the cart, it is difficult to think of them in any other way. Rather like some of those early dinosaur reconstructions and possibly unhelpful in a field as fast-moving as archaeology.

Source: The book of the great sea-dragons, Ichthyosauri and Plesiosauri, [gedolim taninim] gedolim taninim, of Moses. Extinct monsters of the ancient earth. With thirty plates, copied from skeletons in the author’s collection of fossil organic remains, (deposited in the British museum.) by Hawkins, Thomas, 1810-1889
https://archive.org/details/bookgreatseadra00hawk/page/n5/mode/2up

We do this everywhere. Every competitive market is a model, as relentless in its pursuit of victory within the rules (all of which must be stress-tested as to how they are going to be applied by each individual referee in each individual encounter) as the Premier League. Sometimes if you question some of the underlying assumptions behind some of these models, you are told that is just the way the world works.

But the way the world works is opaque. Novelists have attempted to show us glimpses of it for centuries. Historians are sometimes able to agree about how it has worked in a specific geography for a short period of time. Occasionally, as a result of our own experiences, we may feel that we have managed to grasp some truth about the world and how it works in our own lives. But often the clarity slips through our fingers when we throw more light on it. The clarity certainly never seems to last that long. For clarity you often need an organisation signed up to a model.

Much has been written in recent years about our dependence on models and our inability to look outside them in many cases, most notably Escape from Model Land by Erica Thompson. This has mainly focused on the models we make to try and understand the world. But there also models behind those models which effectively determine what kinds of models of the first kind we create. These are the organisations and institutions we look at the world from.

It was in a time of rapid transition and uncertainty much as our own is that the groups of organisations we call professions emerged in the nineteenth century. The model of the second kind they adopted was partly that set out by Daniel and Richard Susskind in their book The Future of the Professions.

According to the Susskinds, there is a Grand Bargain between society and the professions, which means (and I am paraphrasing a little here), in return for professions providing:

  • Expertise, experience and judgement;
  • Delivered affordably, accessibly, reassuringly and reliably;
  • With knowledge and methods maintained and kept up to date, members trained, standards and quality of work enforced and only appropriately qualified individuals allowed in;
  • Acting honestly and in good faith; and
  • Putting clients’ interests ahead of their own.

In return, society will give the professions:

  • Respect and status;
  • Exclusive rights to perform/provide socially significant activities or services; and;
  • Independence to decide how they do it and how much they can be paid for it.

What professions expect from society is jealously guarded. My own profession’s uneasy relationship with the universities can plausibly be traced back to Newton’s influence on what mathematics could be taught there, therefore denying actuaries the status they craved without setting up their own professional bodies to supply it. The last attempt to allow an allied profession to carry out limited medical activities ended with the Leng Review effectively strangling it, egged on noisily by the BMA. And it is not hard to find articles defending increases to executive remuneration way beyond that of the people who work for them as the norm.

What society expects from professions often gets less attention directed at it. Four of the five bullets above tend to form part of the professional code of most professions in some form, although there are frequent fines of large professional firms for failures in the standard of the services provided.

But what of delivering professional services affordably, accessibly, reassuringly and reliably? What has tended to happen, as the group of people requiring professional services has widened, is that the affordability and accessibility have been increasingly called in to question. And online self-service looks likely to be attempted for a wider and wider range of services as time goes on.

So is the professional structure we have going to remain? If the experience of the nineteenth century, when most of these professions emerged, is anything to go by, the level of disruption will vary hugely by profession and institution and the period of transition could be very long in some cases. But it seems clear that such a period has begun. This has serious implications for actuarial education, amongst much else.

And whatever replaces them is likely to be built from the bottom up.

The Charybdis is a swirling water feature in the temperate house at Savill Garden. It was designed by Giles Rayner in 2006. https://funandgames.org/web/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/The-Charybdis_Savill-Gardens_9257-2-scaled.jpg – you may have recently seen the original in The Odyssey

Last week I mentioned that I thought this blog, for the rest of the year at least, would be about what we resist, what we create and what we could nurture in the face of a terrifying future. This week I thought I should start to put a bit of flesh on that particular carcass.

One source for my thinking on this is Alex Steffen. I recently attended one of his Personal Climate Strategy: The Basics webinars. He is particularly good on the importance of continually updating your world view in the face of climate discontinuity and increasing evidence of societal brittleness, and how professions can often be a barrier to doing this:

The greatest danger in any work that asks you to think systemically about the future is getting locked into the worldview that made sense to you when you first began, that you built your successful career on.

We all have limited time and energy. Building up an insightful mental model of how the world works takes a lot of both. The pay-off is in the profit and sense of purpose gained from one’s expertise. It is very common, when you’re highly rewarded for a given set of working insights, to commit more to those insights as your career unfolds, to begin even to defend those insights from challenging new perspectives (ones you fear might devalue your intellectual stock in trade). This “sunk-cost expertise” can easily become a set of shackles.

The article then goes on to explain the process of triangulation, by which professionals can “deflate pressure (from the public, regulators or activist stakeholders) to change more quickly and shore up the power of management and experts who would otherwise be forced to admit that they don’t really know what they’re doing”. If someone starts by saying that they support what you are suggesting, then responds with a bunch of short-term easy actions and claims that these are the start of a journey towards what you are suggesting, you are probably being triangulated.

Another is a recent article by Richard Murphy on the political economy of adaptation. As he says:

The biological idea that first made me think this might be possible is called allostasis. It is not a complicated concept. It simply describes the way living organisms survive by continually adapting to the changing world around them.

As we all know, nothing alive exists in a stable environment. Every living thing must continually respond and adapt to changing circumstances. Human beings are no exception. Our brains and bodies are constantly anticipating change and adjusting to it. Most of that work happens without us ever noticing. Allostasis happens all the time, and most of us do not notice. But the fact is that this continual adaptation has a cost.

Murphy points out that, at a time of continual change like ours, that cost is high. And the adaptation required is much higher for people who cannot just throw money at their problems. He then goes on to say:

That changes how we think about political economy. Politics then becomes the process by which societies decide how those costs of adaptation are distributed, whilst economics becomes the study of how institutions either increase or reduce them. Accounting becomes the means by which we identify who ultimately bears the cost of adaptation and health becomes one of the principal ways in which we observe its effects.

I think there is a lot to this approach, which would also provide a structure to identify and critique the triangulation process set out by Steffen. Murphy only mentions education once in this piece:

Education should recognise that human beings learn differently, rather than assuming that everyone should conform to a single model.

I would go a lot further than that, because I think education is the key to helping individuals with their own adaptation strategies as well as in developing the political understanding to see how the costs of adaptation are currently distributed and how to change that within a democratic system. This seems to be an extension of what I have been writing recently about how not to be a reverse-centaur for instance.

The implications for this in health, education and our institutions are considerable in my view and growing all the time. So that is what I am going to be writing about for a while.

Starting next week with allostasis.

Isaac Newton may or may not have been nutted by an apple. His friend William Stukeley, whose memoir of Newton was the source of the story, states it as follows (spelling and punctuation from Stukeley’s manuscript at the Royal Society):

“why should that apple always descend perpendicularly to the ground,” thought he to him self: occasion’d by the fall of an apple, as he sat in a comtemplative mood: “why should it not go sideways, or upwards? but constantly to the earths centre? assuredly, the reason is, that the earth draws it. there must be a drawing power in matter. & the sum of the drawing power in the matter of the earth must be in the earths center, not in any side of the earth. therefore dos this apple fall perpendicularly, or toward the center. if matter thus draws matter; it must be in proportion of its quantity. therefore the apple draws the earth, as well as the earth draws the apple.”

However there may be stronger grounds for believing that Newton nutted English mathematics and, as a result, the actuarial profession.

I thought all this to myself, occasion’d by participation in the Actuarial Teachers and Researchers Conference (ATRC) this week. It was great. There were lots of interesting talks, and people were very engaged and respectful in how they discussed them. There was a lot of expertise in the room about both education and actuarial practice and theory. It felt like it was a room that could take on difficult topics and make progress in tackling them.

There were several calls for the need to change assessment, one of them by me, whether due to large student cohorts and the difficulties of engaging them, or the ease with which AI can duplicate examination solutions or because the credentials provided by those assessments seem increasingly irrelevant to the actual actionable skills, knowledge and experience required to operate successfully as an actuary. And there was an equally robust response from the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries (IFoA) to the effect that assessments would not be changing significantly in the latest changes due to come in by 2029.

My favourite presentation was by Angus Macdonald, about his recent short paper on Newton, Leibniz and Actuarial Science. It conjectures that the argument between Leibniz and Newton over who invented calculus resulted in the stagnation of mathematics in English universities and meant that actuaries needing to gain respectability for their advice were forced to create a professional body (in company with architects, accountants and engineers) rather than rely on universities to develop actuarial thinking as happened in continental Europe. This stagnation (Macdonald quoted G.H.Hardy, talking about the Cambridge mathematics exams, saying that they had “. . . effectively ruined serious mathematics in England for a hundred years”) was felt across the whole Anglosphere, with attempts to create institutions with equal status to the traditional universities leading to the establishment of business schools in the USA in the late 19th and early 20th centuries.

This explained a lot for me. The suspicion of our actuarial courses amongst some of our mathematics colleagues at times at Leicester. The occasionally uneasy relationship between the IFoA and the accredited universities where students can gain exemptions from their exams. The horror from some at the very idea that an actuary might qualify as a result of university courses, like they can in the Netherlands, for instance. ATRC seemed the appropriate place to explore these ideas.

Angus Macdonald considers that the Newtonian and Leibnizian branches have nearly rejoined, but I feel that our actuarial education system still suffers from the long shadow cast by these two 17th century gentlemen and their personal enmity. The ferocity with which some within the profession opposed what they saw as a threat to the popularity of the fellowship qualification posed by the new chartered actuary designation was hard to explain when the number of practising certificates issued for chief actuaries, pension scheme actuaries, etc was only around 1,100 (out of over 17,000 fellows), but if the whole profession originated from a highly developed form of status anxiety compared to academics, it becomes much easier to understand. As they say, the apple doesn’t fall far from the tree.

Now, nearly 180 years on from this “unstoppable” “rush to respectabilize” (according to Jeremy Paxman) I think it is legitimate to ask:

  1. Why does the IFoA still insist on detailed accreditation of individual university courses on basic mathematics, statistics and business economics? Do they not trust them to teach them right? Do they think that there is something better about learning these universal subjects via a bespoke course created by a tiny professional body with 34,000 members globally?
  2. Why are they so concerned about what assessment methods the universities use? Do they consider that they have more educational expertise on this than some of the leading universities in the world?

I have written previously about the changes in assessment I think are necessary and floated some ideas about where actuarial education might sit to accommodate these. My view was that the IFoA, faced with the need to innovate at all levels of its education system at a time of great uncertainty, might wish to get out of the foundational mathematics and business education tuition of the core principles subjects and leave this to the university system, in a truly Leibnizian way.

However there is a problem. The university system is facing a tough time. UK higher education is shrinking according to the UCU branch at Queen Mary’s, which has set up a a live page of all the redundancies, restructures, reorganisations, and closures taking place across the UK Higher Education (UKHE) sector. The numbers from the Higher Education Statistics Agency (HESA) bear this out, with overall student numbers falling, driven by a 10% fall in overseas entrants with a non-European Union permanent address.

In actuarial science, the list of UK universities offering accredited courses has not changed for some time, and it is a small group within the university system. These courses must be seen as vulnerable. I don’t think it is a coincidence that it is so hard to persuade one of this tiny band to run the ATRC. This week’s was the first since 2021 and the list of past hosts is not very long:

Source: https://atrc.le.ac.uk/

The IFoA needs to ask itself what it would do if there were some high profile closures of actuarial courses and whether perhaps it might be time to protect the core mathematical education arrangements for actuaries through a broad brush accreditation of a wider range of courses, rather than the very detailed accreditation process it currently carries out on core principles subjects.

I also doubt that it has the capacity on its own to significantly restructure its assessments beyond the objective based assessments it has developed to work within its proctored environment.

The core practice and specialist subjects leading to fellowship are the areas where actuaries have, rightly, the strongest views about content and assessment structures. It surely makes sense that the expertise within the profession and the university system are pooled in a joint endeavour rather than risking both failing independently.

In contrast to Newton, who had quite a temper, Leibniz was famously parodied by Voltaire in his Dr Pangloss character in Candide who believed that “All is for the best in this best of all possible worlds.”

Let’s not be too Panglossian about the current state of actuarial education.

A no entry sign over an image of a reverse-centaur where the robot is in control

As I discussed in How Not To Be A Reverse-Centaur (Cory Doctorow defines a reverse-centaur as “a machine that is assisted by a human being, who is expected to work at the machine’s pace”) our actuarial education system needs to change. This has been true for some time, but the development of AI systems has both demonstrated why more clearly and accelerated the timeframes over which action is needed. As I said in December last year:

A large part of the education of the future will need to be about equipping us all to understand what we now have access to and when and how to access it. We will all have different things we are interested in, or end up involved with and needing to be educated about. It will be up to each of us to decide which things are worth the difficulty of learning, but to make those decisions we will need education that can support the development of judgement.

For education institutions, the question will be what is not worth the difficulty of learning? Credentialising based on now relatively meaningless assessment methods will not cut it. This is where the confrontation with employers and politicians is likely to come. Essential skills and their related knowledge will be better developed and assessed via more open-ended project work and online assessment of it to check understanding. These will need to become the norm, with written examinations becoming less and less prevalent. Not because of fear of cheating and plagiarism, but because an outcome which can be replicated that easily by AI is not worth assessing in the first place.

Suppose you were to ask someone who had never seen our academic system that, in order to assess whether someone else we wanted them to employ in their organisation would do a good job for them, we would:

  1. Award marks for what has been written in answer to academic questions about what the students can remember unaided about the content of their lecture courses and reading lists with a biro on a pad of paper perched precariously on a tiny wooden table surrounded by hundreds of other similar scribblers, for a set period of time as minders wandered the floors like Victorian factory owners.
  2. These marks would be based on marking criteria they would never see.
  3. We would then get together in a secret huddle for a couple of months to mark all these scripts, check them and “moderate” them to check they were in line with the previous years’ exercises.
  4. Then out would come the answer (like the Answer of 42 to the Ultimate Question of Life, the Universe and Everything in Douglas Adams’ The Hitchhikers Guide To The Galaxy).

Source: https://hitchhikers.fandom.com/wiki/42

Imagine another world where the kinds of things employers routinely do when trying to decide whether to take on someone as a new member of their organisation are routinely part of their assessments at university, eg:

  • Watch them operating in groups working on a task.
  • Ask them to describe how they would go about tackling a particular problem.
  • Get them to show they understand the implications of a piece of work they have carried out and can explain what assumptions it is based on and can justify them.

With assessments of performance which are not opaque academic exercises but descriptions of performance made as the tasks are being carried out evidenced by video if necessary. In other words, transparent enough to whoever might want to work with these students next to eliminate the gap between their credentials and and their actual actionable skills, knowledge and experience.

Assessing in this way will be highly demanding, for both the students and the assessors, but it means the final assessment is done with the student present and, with careful probing from the assessors, who will obviously need to have done a close reading of the project work beforehand, confidence will be high about the abilities demonstrated by the process. And it removes the need for all the time currently spent on the Victorian factory owner process – imagine what could be done if the whole of May, June and July wasn’t spent marking scripts!

A move like this will significantly change what is taught. There will be no point presenting lots of information in ways which make retention easier for students (the so-called bookwork” questions currently in most exams). This makes sense when you think about how much of the content of your courses is accessible to you now, even on a vocational course like actuarial science, as opposed to skills developed. Instead the focus will be more on conversations with students for the purpose of developing their understanding of a meaty topic and the problems to be solved within it. Explorations of these will form the projects students will be spending most of their time working on. Checking understanding and making sure students are working within frameworks they understand and can talk about will be the main teaching activity, with opportunities to practise these throughout the year. In other words, showing the ability to apply what they have understood and demonstrate the ability to reflect, make judgements and show higher levels of understanding as a result. An ability they can then apply to new problems and situations.

And notice something else about how these alternative credentials are generated? They are all social activities: from operating in groups, to presenting a piece of work to a group of assessors. Even the project work is developed through group sessions alongside individual work. If you want to develop people who can spot the gaps between models and reality you need to do it in groups, where people can test their perspectives against each other.

Compare this to the current solitary exam preparation, peppered with “revision” lectures, exam sitting and exam marking processes which comprise the predominant activities in universities between March and July each year. We are currently being funneled into an ever more solitary professional practice around LLMs. It has become quite accepted for people to do all of their thinking on a subject closeted with perhaps one, two or three LLMs but no other people and then share their analysis with an expectation that other people should read the output. Developing the skills to do these analyses will obviously be necessary, but they will never be the most important skills people learn.

Treating each other like walking databases is never going to make you new friends or influence people. However the skills you develop via an alternative more social education will.

There are examples of this approach already happening, with employers involved in the design of assessments in some cases and universities using the flexibility they have to restructure and redesign courses. But the dominant assessment system of formal exams is keeping much of this activity at the margins at the moment.

If it were to become the dominant assessment, it would also mean that larger areas of the curriculum could be examined, as the focus would not be on retention of large bodies of content but the ability to use the content to solve problems. So, perhaps, after a first year levelling up students’ ability and experience of mathematics and statistics, year 2 would have an actuarial statistics module (currently CS1/CS2) and an actuarial mathematics module (currently CM1/CM2), both dissertation based and vivaed. Then in the third year they would tackle an economics module and a business modules (currently CB1 and CB3). Perhaps in the final year of a four year MAct they would tackle a modelling and communication module (CP2/CP3) and either CP1 actuarial practice module would be offered or a professional skills module.

This would be more of a driving test style of assessment, with students working with supervisors on the comments from assessors on the original dissertations and presentations until they were up to the required standard. Students unable to make the standard after an additional year would be offered a move to a non-accredited course. The current funding model for higher education will need to change: loading students with £10,000 more debt every time they add to the nation’s skills bank with another year wrestling with these difficult skills to master was never a clever strategy, but this structure would make it even clearer how self defeating it is. If economists are accepting that the labour market no longer allocates resources effectively and are considering either a universal basic income or universal basic services, then logically university funding should follow suit.

The implications for the actuarial profession will be even more challenging. I question whether the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries will continue to consider it worth the effort and expense of reconfiguring their entire approach to exam setting, syllabus maintenance, marking, online proctoring, etc for subjects routinely taught throughout the university system for a a variety of purposes, ie the current core principles subjects of mathematics, statistics and business studies.

Whether they retain their own capacity to assess the core practice subjects is a more open question (CP1 Actuarial Practice, I imagine, will be seen as sufficiently specialist to keep in house, with perhaps a few universities, as now, accredited to run courses which can earn this qualification, however CP2 Modelling and CP3 Communications are not nearly as specialised now as they seemed when they were first introduced). I would also move the new core economics module recommended by the IFoA Economics Review Group I chaired in 2022 to replace the current CB2 module into the core practice section, as it would be more of a critical thinking module about the economic ideas necessary to underpin good actuarial work than the technical how-to subjects in core principles.

The specialist stage of the SP and SA subjects and the whole continuing education and additional certification options I would confidently expect the profession to retain, review and adapt as needed to reflect new challenges in members’ working lives. However, if CP1 is all that is needed post graduation to get to Chartered Actuary and CP1, two SP subjects and a SA subject gets you to Fellow, then suddenly time to qualification becomes much more predictable for students and their employers alike.

The risks to employers of taking on students would therefore be reduced, but also the rewards to taking them on will be much more transparent. The students we will be developing will have collapsed the gap between their credentials and their actual actionable skills, knowledge and experience. They will have:

  • Great team working skills;
  • Very highly developed presentation skills, both in writing and speech;
  • Strong IT skills and comfort working with data; and
  • Clarity about why they are in an organisation and a drive to use their skills to solve problems.

They will also have developed the four capabilities set out in Carlo Iacono’s Teach Judgement, Not Prompts:

  1. Epistemic rigour. They will be more likely to spot when a system or model is over-confident given the evidence, after an intense experience of interrogating models and evaluating evidence in their courses.
  2. Synthesis. They will be able to integrate different perspectives into an overall understanding, through dissertation development, defending a position, understanding weaknesses in a position and adjusting accordingly.
  3. Judgement. They will have been asked to make many judgements in their work and had to defend them in discussions with their supervisors and fellow students. Unconvincing opinions, not backed by evidence, will not pass muster.
  4. Cognitive sovereignty. Students will have to take their own stand on their work, after all of the challenge and argument. Independence of thought is the hard-earned outcome here.

And then they will have a fighting chance of being centaurs in the world awaiting them, masters of the technology and opportunities available, rather than the reverse-centaurs that our education system is currently, and inadvertently, preparing them to be.